« Neutrality for thee, but not for me | Main | Belated shouts-out »

04 June 2006

New York Times: Bad things are bad

Hi friends, I have heard loud and clear that I am boring the bejeebus out of you with this net neutrality stuff. So let’s get back to good old, inane, pro-death media bias.

Don Surber does a good job taking apart the latest NYT editorial which celebrates the purported failure of some of our Marines in Haditha. Like most on the right and left, of course I believe they should be tried and the guilty convicted. I also think they should, you know, be tried.

But let’s look at the worst-case scenario. If 7 of our Marines did indeed commit what would be war crimes, what does that say about our people in uniform? Out of 150,000 currently in the field (over 200,000 if you count those that have rotated through) that means that .0035% of our Marines have broken the rules of engagement.

Let’s add in, liberally, 20 people who were purportedly involved with Abu Ghraib. Now we are up to .018% of the military currently in Iraq. That’s just under one-fifth of one-tenth of one percent. Meaning that over 99.9%+ of our folks have acted by the rules, in a situation the difficulty of which you and I will never know.

(Psst — find me a city anywhere in the world, in peacetime, that has such a low crime rate. Or an ethnic group, or a gender, or a faith, or any group at all.)

Now, for those who are outraged at the Haditha accusations: good. It takes great moral courage to say that bad things are bad, I admit. But it is hardly leadership, as many lefties would like to believe.

If the real impetus behind the NYT editorial is that intentional killing is a bad thing (again, moral courage), then I wonder how much editorial ink they they dedicate to the 24,000 innocent civilians that have been targeted and killed by the insurgents?

------

Update: let me pull one passage out, emphasis mine:

Now that we have reached the one place we most wanted to avoid, it will not do to focus blame narrowly on the Marine unit suspected of carrying out these killings and ignore the administration officials, from President Bush on down, who made the chances of this sort of disaster so much greater by deliberately blurring the rules governing the conduct of American soldiers in the field.

What is this “one place”? Two possibilities. The first is that we have reached a place where we are perceived as war criminals, fairly or not. A PR disaster in other words.

I have no doubt this will be a huge, exploitable black eye — with the NYT’s active assistance and regardless of the actual outcome. Well, my notes above tell the basic truth that overwhelmingly, we are not war criminals, and that overwhelmingly, our enemy are. Yet one has to wonder, if the NYT is sincerely concerned about this perception, why do they go to such great lengths to promote it?

The other possibility is that the one place is not about perception, but reality. That our military have indeed lost a moral compass and that they wantonly kill as standard procedure. If that’s the case, then I would imagine something more .018% of them, over three years, might have been accused...

------

Another update and into the breach: Michelle Malkin points out that the military will certainly be painted with a tar brush by those who think themsleves pacifists. But what sort of logic would this follow?

Imagine a redneck, sitting in front of the TV, watching COPS. On the show, a black guy, drunk and violent, is pulled from his house in the midst of beating his wife. Based on his vision of one guy, the redneck points out “Well, they’re just all that way, aren’t they?”

In polite society, we would call this the logic of a “bigot”. On the left, when applied to other select groups, the more appropriate term is “mainstream”.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d83420696553ef00d83426f48053ef

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference New York Times: Bad things are bad:

» We Have Miles to go Before we Sleep from Blue Star Chronicles
I've been spinning my wheels a little lately. Okay a lot. The Haditha story just flew all over me. The liberals/progressives, the MSM, the islamic masses have been having a feeding frenzy at the expense of our Soldiers and our nation. [Read More]

» Haditha Smear Campaign Continues, “More than Just a Few Bad Men” According to the New York Times from Webloggin
The terrorists understand all too well that the American left is more than willing to play the part of mouthpiece for the modern day Goebbels of Al Qaeda. Webloggin translation of the latest NY Times smear Job: The cold blooded killings are yet another... [Read More]

» The Tar Brush from Blue Star Chronicles
Cnn is reporting that the US Military is offering condolences to the families of the slain in Haditha. I think that is improper. It makes us appear weak and invites more accusations. We are in a war and have done enormous good for that country. We ha... [Read More]

Comments

(Psst — find me a city anywhere in the world, in peacetime, that has such a low crime rate. Or an ethnic group, or a gender, or a faith, or any group at all.)

Umm, what about the octogeniarian bingo playing group, I think their rate is lower than that. Thus, your entire argument is ripped to shreds.

Of course the NYT blames bush and the "higher-ups" in the military for the accused actions. Forget about the fact that the insurgents do not wear uniforms, frequenty use women and children as shields or to hide weapons, and the fact that women and children are often insurgents. I would say that these actions "blur the line" more than President Bush.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Email, subscribe, tell your friends

  • Digg! Add to Google

    Add to Technorati Favorites Stumble Upon Toolbar Add to Netvibes


  • Email this page
  • Subscribe via email (enter address below)

    Delivered by FeedBurner

Shameless commerce

Search my site

My Photo

Smarter than I

  • Christopher Hitchens
    Studied liberal who feels the left has abandoned its claim to good will and basic humanity. A cutting and brilliant read.
  • Corner on National Review Online
    The teachers' lounge for leading conservative minds. I check in here all day, every day.
  • Dr. Helen
    Been-there-done-that with the whole death thing. A great read from a former (?) psychologist.
  • Ed Driscoll.com
    A Bay Area conservative and nice enough to offer kind words when I started all this...
  • Gay Patriot
    There is such a thing as a gay conservative!
  • George Will
    Erudite and laugh-out-loud funny.
  • Instapundit
    Glenn Reynolds' always-updated news and law blog
  • La Shawn Barber’s Corner
    Complex and refreshingly direct on race and faith.
  • Michael Barone
    Author of the Almanac of American Politics. Vastly smarter than I.
  • OpinionJournal
    Standard-bearer for the intellectual right. Don't miss Best of the Web every day.
  • Progress & Freedom Foundation Blog
    These folks are working hard to keep the data marketplace free.
  • Protein Wisdom
    Imagine if T.C. Boyle and Hunter Thomspon wrote a right-of-center blog.
  • ScrappleFace
    By Scott Ott. I need a name that rhymes like that. And I also need to be funny.

Friends of OR in SF

  • Lulu Loves Manhattan
    ...but now she is off to London. Foodie blog. British cuisine is the butt of many jokes but I am sure she will guide us well on London eats.
  • [caught In between]
    aka LAGtime, Larry and I often have great discussions on intellectual property, open source and web development.
  • Follow the Crooked Road
    My buddy M@, a man of many ideas. Brand new blog.

Page Counters