« How to find out the value of the yuan | Main | Identity politics on both sides of the aisle »

13 April 2006

You need better sources, and better sources need you (II)

I got a very nice thank-you postcard from Michael Yon yesterday (I had sent him a few bucks). He is on his way back to Iraq (via Afghanistan) to do the stunning, independent, first-hand reporting that you are not seeing in the MSM. Examples here and here. If you want to know what’s happening in Iraq, you need sources like Michael Yon.

Michael Totten is already there, in Kurdistan via Turkey. His approach is much more cultural, ad hoc and from the hip. He really gives you a feel for the place.

They are both doing this on their own, so click through and give them a few bucks if you can.

------

Why do you need these guys? Because our mainstream media are worse than biased. They are straight-up gullible.

It is becoming regular practice for terrorists (and their backers) to stage events for the cameras, knowing that there is a very good chance that it will be reported as fact in the US. Here’s the New York Times on March 27:

The bodies of 30 beheaded men were found on a main highway near Baquba this evening, providing more evidence that the death squads in Iraq are becoming out of control.

Awful. How did the Times find out about it?

Interior Ministry officials said a driver discovered the bodies heaped in a pile next to a highway that links Baghdad to Baquba, a volatile city northeast of the capital that has been wracked by sectarian and insurgent violence.

“Iraq Ministry officials” heard it from “a driver”. Terrible. Who had the grisly task of recovering them?

Iraqi army troops were waiting tonight for American support before venturing into the insurgent-infested area to retrieve them. [...]

But it is not at all clear who killed the 30 men found beheaded this evening. The area where they were discovered is mostly Sunni Arab and controlled by Sunni insurgents. It would be very difficult for Shiite death squads to operate there. Interior Ministry officials said they did not have enough information tonight to identify the victims.

I’ll cut to chase: nobody found 30 bodies. Headline in the NY Times. Heartbreaking news to any feeling person, and evidence that Iraq is spinning out of control. And also entirely false.

------

I was first turned on to this phenomenon last fall when I read this article which deconstructs a series of “action shots” of insurgents in Falluja. All staged for the camera, it turns out, and happily published by the AP.

It also turns out this was the regular beat of AP photographer Bilal Hussein, who has an extraordinary knack for getting the most evocative, behind-the-scenes insurgent photos. He won a Pulitzer Prize. How does he do it? Michelle has a lot more.

Gullibility: even more dangerous than bias.

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/t/trackback/490101/4663805

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference You need better sources, and better sources need you (II):

Comments

Post a comment

If you have a TypeKey or TypePad account, please Sign In

Email, subscribe, tell your friends

  • Digg! Add to Google

    Add to Technorati Favorites Stumble Upon Toolbar Add to Netvibes


  • Email this page
  • Subscribe via email (enter address below)

    Delivered by FeedBurner

Recent Posts

Shameless commerce

Search my site

My Photo

Smarter than I

  • Christopher Hitchens
    Studied liberal who feels the left has abandoned its claim to good will and basic humanity. A cutting and brilliant read.
  • Corner on National Review Online
    The teachers' lounge for leading conservative minds. I check in here all day, every day.
  • Dr. Helen
    Been-there-done-that with the whole death thing. A great read from a former (?) psychologist.
  • Ed Driscoll.com
    A Bay Area conservative and nice enough to offer kind words when I started all this...
  • Gay Patriot
    There is such a thing as a gay conservative!
  • George Will
    Erudite and laugh-out-loud funny.
  • Instapundit
    Glenn Reynolds' always-updated news and law blog
  • La Shawn Barber’s Corner
    Complex and refreshingly direct on race and faith.
  • Michael Barone
    Author of the Almanac of American Politics. Vastly smarter than I.
  • OpinionJournal
    Standard-bearer for the intellectual right. Don't miss Best of the Web every day.
  • Progress & Freedom Foundation Blog
    These folks are working hard to keep the data marketplace free.
  • Protein Wisdom
    Imagine if T.C. Boyle and Hunter Thomspon wrote a right-of-center blog.
  • ScrappleFace
    By Scott Ott. I need a name that rhymes like that. And I also need to be funny.

Friends of OR in SF

  • Lulu Loves Manhattan
    ...but now she is off to London. Foodie blog. British cuisine is the butt of many jokes but I am sure she will guide us well on London eats.
  • [caught In between]
    aka LAGtime, Larry and I often have great discussions on intellectual property, open source and web development.
  • Follow the Crooked Road
    My buddy M@, a man of many ideas. Brand new blog.

Page Counters